« Giving Hurricane Reduction a Rest - Dick LaRosa | Main | Work Output versus Tasks Input, A Qualitative Analysis - John Dunn, Consultant, Ambertec, P.E., P.C. »

July 09, 2011

Comments

Graham Holmes

It all sounds very familiar, John. You don't say whether the reviewers were sticking to neutral territory as a result of some political arm-twisting, or whether they were just unqualified to offer criticism. In my experience, it's usually politics. I was once told not to raise any problems at a design review because the project couldn't be allowed to fail. (In fact, the review was just a box-ticking exercise, because the product was already being deployed.) Heard that before? Of course - remember what happened to Morton Thiokol and NASA when politics stifled scientific criticism. As a designer/developer of electronics and software, I strongly believe in the review process. But if the conclusion has been reached before the review has even been planned, then you may as well take the day off. Sadly, it happens all too often.

Cor van de Water

I guess it depends on the leadership of the manager.
As long as I was managing the hardware devt team, the engineers
had better review any design thoroughly, because I know from
experience that anything you catch early costs wayyy less to
fix than letting it slide into the next phase of devt...
Eventually the customer is going to find it so you do your
darnest to avoid letting it go that far.
But that is just my humble / engineer-speaking opinion.

Frank Walker

Luckily, I haven't had the experiences you have. Although I have met my fair share of incompetent engineers... and even though I hate to generalize, most of these individuals came from schools which are extremely prestigious. Simply put: They were advanced in their career past their capabilities because they had the resume. I took the design review from a (IMHO Junior) Senior engineer as a chance to have dialog and possibly share some knowledge with the person evaluating my design.

All of us came out of school knowing eigenvalues, transforms, and the fundamentals of engineering enough to pass a test. Over the next 5-10 years we are molded into engineers, usually picked up by a mentor who is up for the challenge of growing some talent. (I myself was fortunate in this sense.)

For the most part, design reviews generated reasonable feedback and helped to bring the project together.

We all find individuals who are incompetent, lazy or simply just don't care. From my experience these people typically usually end up moving down the road to something they are actually fit for... usually managment! HA!

Jeff Furman

On occasion, I've been handed a stack of review drawings just before the review meeting; I know I can't do that review justice, regardless of my experience. Perhaps my favorite 'hot button' issue will yield some insight, but that's rolling the dice. That initial pause in a review while participants try to 'do their homework' in place is not a good sign.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)

Editor

  Learn about our  

 free engineering 

consulting referral 

      service at:

 

  IEEE Consultant's 

      Network of 

     Long Island

 

We have over forty 

electrical, electronic, 

mechanical and 

software engineers 

with expertise in more 

than sixty-five categories 

of technology and business. 

All are members of the 

IEEE and adhere to the 

IEEE professional codes 

of ethics. 

No fee is charged for the

referral service. 

Each member is an 

independent consultant 

and negotiates his/her 

own consulting agreement.

 

Editor: Jerry Brown

Contributors:

John Dunn

Marty Kanner

Murray Kleiner

Dick LaRosa

David Pinkowitz

Carl Schwab

Gerry Bodner

Larry Rachman

 

Unless otherwise noted, 

reprinting or republication 

of anarticle on this blog is 

authorized by crediting the 

author and prominently 

displaying the following 

sentence at the beginning 

or end of the article,

including the hyperlink to

IEEE Consultant's Network 

of Long Island


"This report is republished 

with permission of IEEE 

Consultant's Network of 

Long Island"

 

Pages

Blog powered by Typepad

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner